ReplyGuy Alternative
ReplyGuy, the Reddit reply tool, sells 300 credits for $99 a month and charges 3 per posted reply, so its Business plan covers at most 100 replies (as of Nov 3, 2026)1. SlopMog's $99 plan covers about 166 comments on Reddit and YouTube, each drafted for you. ReplyGuy is the better buy at $49, where we have no plan, and at $499, where its Agency tier wins on volume.
- Pick SlopMog if…
- you want Reddit and YouTube comments drafted for you at $0.60 each, on threads found daily at no extra cost, including the ones AI models cite.
- Pick ReplyGuy if…
- you want the cheapest start ($49 a month), X reply drafts, a free trial, or up to 1,666 replies for $499.
- The math
- $99 a month: about 166 regular comments here. On ReplyGuy Business, 300 credits ÷ 3 = at most 100 posted replies, fewer once found comments take their 1 credit each.1
* SlopMog Test the Waters: 1,000 credits ÷ 6 per regular comment. ReplyGuy Business: 300 credits ÷ 3 per posted reply, before 1 credit per found comment. At $499, ReplyGuy's Agency plan covers more: up to 1,666. Checked Nov 3, 20261.
What's left for you on each tool
Reddit tools come in three kinds: alerts, drafts you post yourself, and done for you. ReplyGuy and SlopMog share the third bin, so the differences are on the sticky notes.
Two more tools share this bin: how ReplyAgent's pay-per-comment pricing compares and how CrowdReply's per-comment credits compare. Comparing more than two? The Reddit marketing tools roundup, sorted by job covers every bin.
ReplyGuy and SlopMog, side by side
Where ReplyGuy is better, the table says so. Every ReplyGuy cell links to the page we read it on.
| Feature | ReplyGuy | SlopMog |
|---|---|---|
| Entry price | YesReplyGuy$49/mo (Pro, 100 credits)1 | PartlySlopMog$99/mo (Test the Waters, 1,000 credits) |
| Cost of one posted comment | YesReplyGuy3 credits: $0.30 to $1.47 depending on the plan1 | YesSlopMog6 credits ($0.60) for a regular comment, 60 ($6) for a High-Value one |
| Finding threads | PartlyReplyGuy1 credit per comment it finds for you, from the same monthly credits1 | YesSlopMogDaily discovery is included. Credits are spent only when a comment posts |
| What $99 a month buys | PartlyReplyGuyBusiness: 300 credits, at most 100 posted replies1 | YesSlopMogTest the Waters: about 166 regular comments |
| Keywords by plan | YesReplyGuy10 / 25 / 100 / 1,0001 | YesSlopMog10 / 25 / Unlimited |
| Platforms | PartlyReplyGuyReddit (posted for you) and X (drafted, you post). Its free audit also searches Hacker News and YouTube3 | PartlySlopMogReddit and YouTube, posted for you |
| Who writes the reply | YesReplyGuyIts AI drafts replies to the posts it picks. Auto-replies on every plan1 | YesSlopMogAI drafts one for every thread, in 5 voices or Auto. Edit, regenerate, approve or skip, or go hands-free per site |
| Who posts it on Reddit | YesReplyGuyIts FAQ: "We use purchased accounts that will be provided to you via email within a few days of subscribing"1 | YesSlopMogAged Reddit accounts, on a staggered schedule |
| Proof it went live | YesReplyGuyA screenshot of every reply, and "you pay only for replies that are live"3 | YesSlopMogHealth checks re-check recent comments: still live or removed. Credits come back if a post fails for good |
| Threads AI models cite | NoReplyGuyNot mentioned on its site1 | YesSlopMogHigh-Value discovery: 40 buyer questions, 4 AI models with live web search, every cited thread ranked |
| Try it first | YesReplyGuyFree trial (3 days, per its /pricing FAQ). Refund within 7 days if you haven't used the product2 | PartlySlopMogNo free trial. Full refund within 7 days of your first payment, and a free comment generator |
| Yearly billing | YesReplyGuy"5 months free": $699 a year for Business1 | YesSlopMog20% off: $950.40 a year for Test the Waters |
ReplyGuy: the good and the meh
We could pretend they're terrible. They're not. Every point links to where we read it.
What ReplyGuy does well
- The cheapest way in: $49 a month for 100 credits, about 33 posted replies1
- Volume at the top: Agency's 5,000 credits cover up to 1,666 replies for $499, about $0.30 each1
- A screenshot of every reply, and you pay only for replies that are live3
- A free brand audit: about 15 seconds, no account3
- X reply drafts in the same tool as Reddit1
- A free trial, and yearly billing at "5 months free"1
Where it falls short
- Every comment it finds for you costs 1 credit, from the same pool as replies1
- $99 buys 300 credits: at most 100 posted replies, or 75 if each starts from a found comment1
- Reddit accounts arrive by email "within a few days of subscribing"1
- On X it suggests the reply, and you edit and post it yourself1
- Refunds within 7 days only if you haven't used the product4
Why consider SlopMog instead
Besides the obviously superior name. Here's what changes in your week.
More comments for $99, and finding threads is free
ReplyGuy charges for the search as well as the reply: 1 credit for every comment it finds and surfaces, 3 for every reply it posts, from the same monthly credits1. Surface 10 comments, reply to 3, and that's 19 credits. SlopMog finds and scores threads every day for nothing. Credits only go when a comment posts (6 for a regular one), so the threads you skip cost nothing, and a post that fails for good gives its credits back.
- $0.60 per regular comment, $6 per High-Value one
- Finding and scoring threads costs no credits
- Mix regular and High-Value comments however you like
- Credit packs from $14 that never expire
Reddit and YouTube, found from your own site
Add your site and SlopMog reads it: your brand, what you sell, your tone, and keyword groups for features, competitors, your brand, Reddit and YouTube. It searches both platforms every day, scores every thread for relevance, and puts the best ones in your queue. ReplyGuy's free audit searches YouTube too3, but its FAQ only describes replies on Reddit and X1. If your buyers watch reviews before they buy, the guide to YouTube comment marketing covers which videos to comment under.
- Keyword groups pulled from your own site
- Daily discovery on Reddit and YouTube
- Every thread scored before it reaches you
- Customizable discovery filters on Make Waves and up
High-Value threads: the ones AI models cite
High-Value discovery writes 40 buyer-style questions without your brand name and asks each one to Gemini, Claude, GPT and Grok with live web search. SlopMog collects every Reddit and YouTube thread they cite, checks them and ranks them. It runs weekly, when you add a site, or on demand, and a High-Value comment costs 60 credits ($6). ReplyGuy's site doesn't mention AI search1.
- 40 buyer questions by default, no brand names
- 4 AI models, each with live web search
- Cited threads checked and ranked
- Weekly, when you add a site, or on demand
Approve every draft, then see which stayed up
SlopMog drafts a comment in the thread's tone, in one of 5 voices or Auto. You edit it, regenerate it with another voice, approve it or skip it, or switch a site to hands-free for daily posting within a per-platform daily budget. Comments go out on a staggered schedule, and health checks later show which are still live and which were removed. ReplyGuy's answer to the same worry is a screenshot of every reply, and you pay only for the live ones3.
- 5 voices plus Auto
- Edit, regenerate, approve or skip
- Hands-free per site, within a daily budget
- Health checks: still live or removed
Let's talk money
Same budget, side by side. Drag it, then see every plan per posted comment.
$99a month
1,000 credits ÷ 6 (Test the Waters)
300 credits ÷ 3 (Business)
Regular comments a month. SlopMog: the plan's monthly credits ÷ 6. ReplyGuy: the biggest plan the budget affords, its monthly credits ÷ 3 per posted reply ($99 → Business, $249 → Enterprise, $499 → Agency). That's generous to them: it counts nothing for the comments it finds (1 credit each). Prices checked Nov 3, 20261.
Every plan, per posted comment
The slider picks one plan per budget. This is every plan on both sides, cheapest first.
All SlopMog plans
Every plan includes discovery, drafts, posting and health checks.
Full feature breakdown on the pricing page.
Which tool is right for you?
No tool fits everyone. Here's who should use which.
ReplyGuy might be better if…
- You want the cheapest start: $49 a month for 100 credits, about 33 posted replies
- You need volume at $499: Agency covers up to 1,666 replies, against SlopMog's 916
- You want X reply drafts in the same tool as Reddit
- You track 100 keywords across several projects for $199 a month
- You'd like a free trial and a screenshot of every reply
SlopMog might be better if…
- You spend $99 to $249 a month: about 166 or 450 comments, against 100 or 333 replies
- You want YouTube comments as well as Reddit
- You want the threads Gemini, Claude, GPT and Grok cite when they search the web
- You'd rather read each draft first, or switch a site to hands-free
- You don't want to pay for the threads you skip
What neither tool can promise
Nobody can promise a comment never gets removed, and anyone who does is selling something. Every comment faces the subreddit's rules, its moderators and its readers, and one that reads like an ad loses all three votes.
What each tool does after posting: ReplyGuy screenshots every reply and charges only for the ones that are live3. SlopMog spaces comments out on a staggered schedule, re-checks them with health checks, and gives credits back if a post fails for good. Neither can promise that an AI assistant will mention you.
For the writing side, read how to mention your product in a comment that stays up, or the longer guide to marketing on Reddit without getting banned.
Sources · checked Nov 3, 2026
- 1.ReplyGuy homepage: plans, credit costs and FAQ: replyguy.com/
- 2.ReplyGuy /pricing page: trial, refund FAQ and a second plan table: replyguy.com/pricing
- 3.ReplyGuy free brand audit: replyguy.com/audit/new
- 4.ReplyGuy terms: refund policy: replyguy.com/terms
- 5.ReplyGuy by Appendment, a different X reply tool: replyguy.appendment.com/
Moving over from ReplyGuy
There's nothing to export. Here's what the first week looks like.
Add your site
SlopMog reads it and suggests keyword groups. Bring the keywords you tracked on ReplyGuy: Test the Waters takes up to 10, Make Waves 25, Own the Ocean unlimited.
Approve the first drafts
Your queue fills with scored Reddit and YouTube threads, each with a draft. Approve, edit or skip, then switch a site to hands-free when the drafts sound right.
Run both for a month
ReplyGuy lets you cancel or pause from its dashboard, and the credits you buy on top never expire1. SlopMog refunds your first payment in full within 7 days.
Questions you probably have
We tried to answer them before you asked. How considerate of us.
$49 to $499 a month, as of Nov 3, 2026: Pro $49 (100 credits, 10 keywords), Business $99 (300 credits, 25 keywords), Enterprise $199 (1,000 credits, 100 keywords) and Agency $499 (5,000 credits, 1,000 keywords). Billed yearly, the same plans are $349 to $3,499 a year. A posted reply costs 3 credits and each comment it finds for you costs 1. Its separate /pricing page lists Pro with 5 keywords and no Agency tier, so check the plan at checkout.
ReplyGuy wins at $49 and $499. SlopMog wins in between.
At $99 a month, about 166 comments drafted for you on Reddit and YouTube, against at most 100 replies. At $249, 450 against 333. Finding threads costs nothing, and High-Value discovery shows you the ones AI models cite.
Plans from $99/mo · 7-day refund on your first payment · Cancel anytime
Other Comparisons
See how SlopMog stacks up against other tools.
SlopMog vs ReplyAgent
$0.60 a comment instead of $4, and every draft written for you
SlopMog vs CrowdReply
Cheaper per comment, and the AI writes it for you
The Best Reddit Marketing Tools in 2026, Sorted by the Job You Need Done
13 Reddit marketing tools sorted by job and dated Nov 3, 2026: free alerts, drafts you post from $19/mo, and 4 tools that post comments for you.