Replymer Alternative
Replymer's $99 Starter plan drafts 30 replies a month, and on Reddit you post each one yourself (as of Nov 3, 2026). SlopMog's $99 plan covers about 166 regular comments and posts them for you, on Reddit and YouTube. Same price, fewer buttons for you to press.
- Pick SlopMog if…
- you want Reddit and YouTube comments posted for you at $0.60 each, approved one by one or hands-free.
- Pick Replymer if…
- you'd rather post on Reddit from your own account, need X too, or want AI visibility tracking across 6 engines in one plan.
- The math
- $99 a month buys about 166 posted comments here, or 30 replies there that you post yourself on Reddit.1
What changed at Replymer in 2026
Replymer's plans cost the same $99, $199, $399 as in June 2026, for the same 30, 100, 300 replies. On Reddit, the person pressing Post changed.
| What | June 8, 2026 | Nov 3, 2026 |
|---|---|---|
| Who writes the reply | June“Our writers (real humans)”6 | NovAI drafts one for every relevant thread1 |
| Who posts on Reddit | June“Our publishing team”, from “our network of established accounts”6 | NovYou, “in one click, from your own account”1 |
| Who posts on X | JuneThe same publishing team6 | Nov“X publishes automatically”1 |
| Your approval | JuneNot needed: “No, it's fully automated”6 | Nov“Nothing is ever posted without you”1 |
| Free trial | June“Start with a free trial”6 | NovNone, per its FAQ and its terms2 |
| Plans | June$99 / $199 / $399 a month for 30 / 100 / 300 replies6 | NovThe same $99 / $199 / $399 for the same 30 / 100 / 300 replies1 |
New since June: AI visibility tracking across 6 engines on every plan1, and an MCP server so your own AI agent can work the queue3. SEO Replies, which posted replies in threads that rank on Google, isn't taking new customers, though current subscribers keep their plan5.
One line above Replymer's price cards still says “Free to try, no card”. Its FAQ and its terms both say there's no free trial, so this page goes by those2. If posting from your own account suits you, SlopMog vs Redreach covers the other tool built that way.
* $99 ÷ 30 replies on Replymer Starter vs 1,000 credits ÷ 6 on Test the Waters, checked Nov 3, 20261. On Reddit a Replymer reply is a draft you post, and on X it posts itself. Its Scale plan works out to $1.33 a reply.
Replymer and SlopMog, side by side
Where Replymer is better, the table says so. Every Replymer cell links to the page we read it on.
| Feature | Replymer | SlopMog |
|---|---|---|
| Starting price | YesReplymer$99/mo Starter: 30 replies, 15 keywords1 | YesSlopMog$99/mo Test the Waters: 1,000 credits (about 166 regular comments), 10 keywords |
| Replies a month | YesReplymer30 / 100 / 300 replies for $99 / $199 / $3991 | YesSlopMogAbout 166 / 450 / 916 regular comments for $99 / $249 / $499, or 16 / 45 / 91 High-Value ones (or a mix) |
| Cost per reply | PartlyReplymer$3.30 on Starter, $1.99 on Growth, $1.33 on Scale1 | YesSlopMog$0.60 a regular comment, $6 a High-Value one, on every plan |
| Platforms | YesReplymerReddit and X1 | YesSlopMogReddit and YouTube |
| Who writes the reply | YesReplymerAI drafts one for every relevant thread, and you review and edit it1 | YesSlopMogAI drafts one for every thread in the thread's tone, in one of 5 voices or Auto. Edit, regenerate, approve or skip it |
| Who posts it on Reddit | PartlyReplymerYou, "in one click, from your own account", or your own AI agent from your browser over MCP1 | YesSlopMogSlopMog, from aged Reddit accounts, on a staggered schedule (never a burst) |
| Hands-off option | PartlyReplymerX replies publish automatically. For Reddit, a "fully managed" setup means asking about its Scale Elite plan (no published price)4 | YesSlopMogHands-free mode per site: daily posting within a per-platform daily budget, no approvals |
| Threads AI answers cite | YesReplymerDrafts a reply for "every cited discussion you are missing from"1 | YesSlopMogHigh-Value discovery asks Gemini, Claude, GPT and Grok 40 buyer questions with live web search and ranks the threads they cite |
| AI visibility tracking | YesReplymer6 engines on every plan (ChatGPT, AI Overviews, AI Mode, Perplexity, Gemini, Claude), weekly1 | PartlySlopMogTracks when AI chatbots mention you, on Make Waves and up |
| Checks it stayed up | YesReplymerEach published reply is tracked with its link and status1 | YesSlopMogHealth checks re-check posted comments and show which are live and which were removed |
| API / MCP | YesReplymerMCP server and API key on every paid plan3 | NoSlopMogNo public API |
| Try it first | PartlyReplymerNo free trial. Refunds within 7 days of purchase if you haven't used the product2 | PartlySlopMogNo free trial. Full refund within 7 days of your first payment, plus a free comment generator |
| Billing | YesReplymerMonth-to-month, cancel anytime1 | YesSlopMogMonthly, or yearly at 20% off. Cancel anytime |
Replymer: the good and the meh
We could pretend they're terrible. They're not. Every point links to where we read it.
What Replymer does well
- Covers X as well as Reddit, and X replies post automatically1
- AI visibility tracking across 6 engines is included on every plan1
- An MCP server, so your own AI agent can work the queue and post Reddit replies from your browser3
- Reddit replies go out from your own account: "Our tools never touch your social accounts"1
- Your agent can also send outreach emails to the sites AI answers cite, from your own address3
- Unlimited keywords on Scale at $399/mo, and every plan is month-to-month1
Where it falls short
- On Reddit you post every reply yourself. Its listed plans no longer post Reddit replies for you1
- 30 replies on the $99 Starter plan works out to $3.30 a reply1
- No YouTube1
- No free trial, and refunds only within 7 days if you haven't used the product2
- SEO Replies, its Google-ranking-thread service, isn't taking new customers5
Why consider SlopMog instead
Besides the obviously superior name. Here's what changes in your week.
SlopMog posts the Reddit comment for you
Replymer's live plans hand you each Reddit reply to post from your own account1. SlopMog drafts a comment for every thread it finds, in the thread's tone and one of 5 voices (or Auto). Edit it, regenerate it, approve it or skip it, and SlopMog posts it from an aged Reddit account on a staggered schedule. Or switch a site to hands-free and skip the approving too.
- Approve each draft, or go hands-free per site
- Posted from aged Reddit accounts, spaced out, never in a burst
- Reddit and YouTube threads found every day
- Health checks show which comments are still live
About 5x the replies for the same $99
Replymer Starter is $99 a month for 30 replies as of Nov 3, 2026, about $3.30 each1. SlopMog's Test the Waters is also $99 and comes with 1,000 credits. A regular comment is 6 of them ($0.60), so the month covers about 166. At the top of both ladders it's 300 replies for $399 against about 916 comments for $499.
- $0.60 a regular comment, $6 a High-Value one
- Credits are spent only when a comment posts
- Credits come back if a post fails for good
- Credit packs from $14 that never expire
The threads AI models cite, with a comment in them
Replymer's newer pitch is AI visibility: it tracks 6 engines and drafts a reply for every cited discussion you're missing from, which you then post1. SlopMog's High-Value discovery writes 40 buyer-style questions without your brand name, asks Gemini, Claude, GPT and Grok with live web search, and ranks every Reddit and YouTube thread they cite. Then it drafts the comment and posts it. If measuring is the main job, a dedicated AI visibility tracker measures more than either of us.
- 40 buyer questions by default, no brand name
- Gemini, Claude, GPT and Grok, each with live web search
- Runs weekly, when you add a site, or on demand
- A High-Value comment is 60 credits ($6)
Let's talk money
Same budget. Very different month. Drag it.
$99a month
1,000 credits ÷ 6 (Test the Waters)
30 comments on Starter ($99/mo)
Regular comments a month. SlopMog: the plan's monthly credits ÷ 6. Replymer: the replies in the biggest plan the budget affords (Starter $99: 30, Growth $199: 100, Scale $399: 300). We count every Replymer reply as a comment, though on Reddit each one is a draft you post yourself. Prices checked Nov 3, 20261.
All SlopMog plans
Every plan includes discovery, drafts, posting and health checks.
Full feature breakdown on the pricing page.
What people say about Replymer
We don't paraphrase strangers. Here's where to read them yourself.
That's every review as of Nov 3, 2026: one review from January 2026, before the relaunch, and one from August 2026. Two reviews can't tell you much either way, so read them yourself instead of taking a competitor's summary.
Read Replymer's reviews on TrustpilotWhich tool is right for you?
Comparing more than two tools? The Reddit marketing tools roundup sorts them by job. Two more that post for you: SlopMog vs CrowdReply and SlopMog vs ReplyAgent.
Replymer might be better if…
- You want to post on Reddit from your own account and press Post yourself
- You need X as well as Reddit, with X replies posted automatically
- You want AI visibility tracking across 6 engines in the same plan
- You want your own AI agent to work the queue over MCP
- You want unlimited keywords for $399 a month
SlopMog might be better if…
- You bought Replymer to have Reddit replies posted for you
- You want more replies for the money: about 166 for $99 instead of 30
- You want YouTube threads as well as Reddit
- You'd rather approve drafts, or go hands-free, than post each one
- You want comments in the threads Gemini, Claude, GPT and Grok cite
What neither tool can promise
Nobody can promise a comment never gets removed, and anyone who does is selling something. Replymer puts each Reddit reply on your own account and leaves the posting to you. SlopMog posts from aged Reddit accounts, spaces comments out, and re-checks them later, so your dashboard shows which ones are still up. Including the ones a mod didn't love.
On either tool, what the comment says carries most of the weight. An ad has to get past the sidebar rules, the mods and then the readers. Answer the question in the thread first and mention the product second. How to market on Reddit without getting banned covers the rest of the craft.
Sources · checked Nov 3, 2026
- 1.Replymer homepage and pricing (plans, FAQ, AI Visibility, MCP): replymer.com/
- 2.Replymer terms (no free trial, refund policy): replymer.com/terms
- 3.Replymer AI agent and MCP page: replymer.com/ai-agent
- 4.Replymer Reddit comment service page (managed setups): replymer.com/reddit-comment-service
- 5.Replymer SEO Replies page (paused for new customers): replymer.com/reddit-seo-replies
- 6.Replymer homepage as archived on June 8, 2026 (Wayback Machine): web.archive.org/web/20260608084532/https://www.replymer.com/
- 7.Replymer reviews on Trustpilot: trustpilot.com/review/replymer.com
- 8.ParseStream's Replymer review (Replymer's plans as read on Aug 14, 2026): parsestream.com/replymer-review
Moving over from Replymer
There's nothing to export. Here's what the first week looks like.
Add your site
SlopMog reads it and pulls out your brand, what you sell, your tone and keyword groups. Daily discovery on Reddit and YouTube starts from there, and your Replymer keyword list is a handy check on what it picks.
Choose how hands-on to be
Approve each draft as it lands in your queue, or switch the site to hands-free for daily posting within a per-platform daily budget.
Keep X where it is
Replymer is month-to-month1, so if X matters to you, keep a plan there for X and let SlopMog handle Reddit and YouTube. Or run both for a month and compare.
Questions you probably have
We tried to answer them before you asked. How considerate of us.
Yes on X, no on Reddit. X replies publish automatically, but since its 2026 relaunch Replymer drafts each Reddit reply and you post it from your own account in one click, or your own AI agent posts it from your browser over MCP (as of Nov 3, 2026). Its June 2026 homepage said its publishing team posted replies from its own network of accounts. For a fully managed setup, its comment-service page points to a Scale Elite plan with no published price.
Replymer hands you the Reddit draft. SlopMog posts it.
About 166 regular comments for $99 a month, each drafted in the thread's tone and posted for you on Reddit and YouTube. Approve them one by one, or switch a site to hands-free and let them go.
Plans from $99/mo · 7-day refund on your first payment · Cancel anytime
Other Comparisons
See how SlopMog stacks up against other tools.